Katya Reimann, Writer & Artist
Add text
  • Home
  • Writing
    • Books
    • Wind From a Foreign Sky
    • A Tremor in the Bitter Earth
    • Prince of Fire & Ashes
    • The Wanderer
    • German Editions
  • Artwork
    • Modes
    • Paintings
    • Drawings
    • Indian Sketchbook
    • Beadwork
    • Quirky
  • About Katya
    • Bio
    • William Page Reimann
    • Helen Sadowy Reimann
  • Blog/Contact

Bad Art History

2/10/2015

0 Comments

 
Picture
I was recently looking for a certain type of face, and William Bouguereau's (1825-1905) late work Priestess (1902) caught my attention.  Bouguereau, I quickly discovered, has a less-than-enviable reputation:  "As the quintessential salon painter of his generation, he was reviled by the Impressionist avant-garde"--and it's not just Wikipedia who is saying this.
Picture

Scanning the internet for a quick, more general look at Bouguereau's artwork, I could see why Bouguereau's reputation has suffered since his glory days as one of the most popular painters in France.  But still, I was interested--enough to call up what books might be available on him via Inter-library loan. 

Bouguereau is the artist of some surprisingly familiar paintings--when my books came, I was not surprised to read this line in one appreciation:  "reproductions of Bouguereau's paintings are frequently the best-sellers in their respective museum shops, and the curators, responding like the nineteenth-century critics, despair over the public's taste."

But what did surprise me was... the books I ordered up on Bouguereau.... I'm sorry, but they were not good books.  I completely understand the cultural tick that causes people to sneer at those who choose to go to college to major in Art History.  Yes, yes, I know.  How is one to earn a living in that field?  But--how truly frustrating, to be unable to discover any kind of decent analysis of an artist who has retained his popularity for more than a century.

Don't get me wrong--I'm no rabid fan of the Victorian Alma-Tadema school.  I like my Impressionist paintings.  But there are some pictures by Bouguereau, or a series of pictures, that I find very interesting.

Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Are these the same person?  Members of the same family?  What was the artist's relationship to this model?  I'm not the first person to be interested by this question.  And yet--the art books I received through Inter-Library loan--they did absolutely nothing to address this question.  Page after page of (ghastly) multi-figured quasi historical paintings were reproduced--at the expense of reproducing his more popular "genre" small groupings pictures--and, worse than this, there was almost nothing by way of commentary on the people who appeared in the paintings.  Bouguereau, one author complained, was not much of a letter-writer.  He kept close at home, "his personal life was his own." 

Really?  It seems to me... if, as a researcher, your only source for personal details is a man's (or perhaps his wife's) personal letters and perhaps his journal... you are not much of a researcher.  You have plucked the low hanging fruit, and moved on.  It's sheer laziness.  Why not even a catalog, distinguishing the figures appearing in each painting?  Perhaps this might be guesswork, but you could acknowledge your guesses, and the work wouldn't be in vain.  You'd be laying the groundwork for the next researching generation, giving a place to start, allowing us a better understanding of these paintings.

Who is this girl, aging before Bouguereau's eyes into a young woman?  A servant?   A paid model?  What did she mean to the man, to the painter?  What could an investigation of the man's interactions with his subjects reveal about the psychology behind these paintings?

It seems to me the Art Historians who are filling out the written columns that accompany the plate reproductions--they really don't have much feeling for what they are looking at, or for, or even why people continue to like this man's paintings.  Okay, Bouguereau's not a Millet, ennobling the dirt and the sweat and the work, in a peasant setting, and he's not an innovator when it comes to the surface and brushwork of a painting.  But there's still something interesting here.  Why not dig out that story?
0 Comments
    Egyptian Falcoln at the MET

    Author

    Katya Reimann is a writer & artist living in Saint Paul, Minnesota.


    Picture
    Garden

    Archives

    April 2018
    March 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    April 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    January 2016
    August 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    June 2014
    May 2014
    September 2012
    August 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012

    Categories

    All
    Archive
    Art I Love
    Book News
    Bookshelf
    Katya's Artwork
    Life
    Site Updates/Housekeeping
    Writing

    RSS Feed

    Sites I recommend

    These ones are maintained by long-time personal friends.

    Bensozia
    John Bedell is an archaeologist, historian, and father of five living in Maryland. His blog is a fascinating grab-bag of historical, artistic, and political materials.  This entry about work and leisure gives a good example of his voice.

    William Reimann
    is a consummate artist.  There are so many images to enjoy on this site.  His carved wooden long-leaf red pine Rhinoceros (which he made for me when I was ~11 years old)  is a personal favorite.

    Metro Bikes Trails Guide
    (St. Paul, MN)
    "Reviews and Reports on over 70 bicycle paths in the Minneapolis/Saint Paul area!"
    Maintained by the tireless Seamus Flynn, and a great little site for those local to the Twin Cities area.

    Starless River
    Is the U.K. based caving gear store run by serious hard-ass Tony Seddon. This link goes to the 'caves' section of the store's site--complete with alarming portrait photo of Tony ("After 7 days underground and 700m prussiking").

    The Oxford University
    Cave Club
    Maintained by Steve Roberts, a guy who is extraordinary in so many ways, I'll just limit myself here to saying "Steve is a man who knows about motors."

    Earthsign Studios
    This is Liz Manicatide (now Liz LaManche), principal at Emphasis Creative's personal art & graphics site.  I love Liz's work, panache, and aerial artistry, which leads me to--

    Flying Squirrel Consortium

    Phil Servita's site, and the place to go for custom fabricated circus equipment (either freestanding or fixed point), and aerial classes, if you happen to live in the area.

    Paul Nordberg
    Paul's site is... unique, authentic, & expressive, and pretty much exactly what I think of when I think of a website as an artform.

    Sites I enjoy

    I don't know these people, but I appreciate their work.

    What's That Bug?
    The title says it all.  An incredibly useful site for both the non-bug-phobic & the consummate bug-phobe.

    Margaret & Helen
    Best Friends for Sixty Years and Counting…

    Raging Grannies
    Okay, I'm nowhere near a grandmother, but I very much appreciate what these women are trying to do.  Especially the fact-checking part.

    Dog-shaming
    This site is ridiculous.  The home-made signage is the best.

Katya's Web (Footer Logo)
© 2015 Katya Reimann
✕